In Baywatch Season 9, Episode 5, titled “The Natural,” the story revolves around mysterious rescues taking place on the beach and the surprising identity behind them. At the start of the episode, lifeguards Cody and J.D. notice that swimmers and beachgoers are being saved in unusual ways, but without any lifeguard in sight. Rumors spread quickly about a so-called “Phantom Lifeguard,” an unknown figure who appears just in time to rescue people in distress and then disappears. This mystery intrigues the team, who begin to question who could be behind these brave but unorthodox interventions.

Meanwhile, a subplot focuses on Ed Symes, an annoying medical supply salesman who constantly tries to push his products onto the Baywatch crew. His clumsy behavior and relentless sales pitch create comic relief but also add to the frustrations of the team, especially Mitch, who must balance managing his staff with keeping the beach safe.
The main rescue sequence occurs when a man becomes trapped in quicksand-like sand on the beach. Several bystanders, including two young men and a woman, try to pull him out but fail. The situation becomes critical as the victim sinks deeper, and only a coordinated effort from the Baywatch crew, along with a rescue vehicle, finally saves his life. This dramatic rescue underscores the dangers of hidden sinkholes near the shoreline.
Eventually, the Phantom Lifeguard is revealed to be Jessie Owens, a maintenance worker who quietly uses her natural skills and courage to save lives. Her hidden heroism earns the respect of the team, who welcome her more fully into their ranks.
The episode blends suspense, drama, and light comedy, while highlighting the courage, teamwork, and resourcefulness that define Baywatch.